Oct 16, 2017 12:20
6 yrs ago
1 viewer *
Spanish term
cómo vaya instrumentándose su papel
Spanish to English
Social Sciences
Social Science, Sociology, Ethics, etc.
This little section is causing me much grief. I will break it up into a couple questions. The whole thing is a problem, nu the main problem areas are "Poco imaginaban los atribuidos precursores" and "cómo vaya instrumentándose su papel".
Castilian Spanish to UK English
Orignal
...si algo parece seguro es que un ingrediente dominante del futuro va a ser la Red. O, dicho de otra manera, todo tiende a evolucionar adherido a cómo vaya instrumentándose su papel. Poco imaginaban los atribuidos precursores por dónde acabaría discurriendo la realidad que trataban de impulsar… poco más de medio siglo atrás.
VERY rough draft
...if anything is a certainty, it is that the Internet will play a dominant role in our future. Or, put another way, everything tends to evolve according to how its role is played. Little did they imagine where the ascribed precursors they tried to promote would lead to only a little more than half a century earlier.
Castilian Spanish to UK English
Orignal
...si algo parece seguro es que un ingrediente dominante del futuro va a ser la Red. O, dicho de otra manera, todo tiende a evolucionar adherido a cómo vaya instrumentándose su papel. Poco imaginaban los atribuidos precursores por dónde acabaría discurriendo la realidad que trataban de impulsar… poco más de medio siglo atrás.
VERY rough draft
...if anything is a certainty, it is that the Internet will play a dominant role in our future. Or, put another way, everything tends to evolve according to how its role is played. Little did they imagine where the ascribed precursors they tried to promote would lead to only a little more than half a century earlier.
Proposed translations
(English)
Proposed translations
+3
1 hr
Spanish term (edited):
todo tiende a evolucionar adherido a cómo vaya instrumentándose su papel
Selected
future developments will in all likelihood be determined by how its [proper] role is defined
In my reading, “su papel” here refers to the “Red,” which is a singular subject.
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
Comment: "Thanks!"
+1
46 mins
to how its role as an instrument will evolve
My take
Peer comment(s):
agree |
Marcelo González
: according to how its role as an instrument evolves (without 'will')
14 hrs
|
Thanks!
|
35 mins
to the role they are given/ to what their role becomes
"In other words, the way things tend to evolve is closely tied to the role they assume/are given/take on" or "...to what their role becomes"
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 49 mins (2017-10-16 13:10:13 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
I understand the text to mean that we can't know where a discovery will take us until people start actually doing things with that knowledge. A classic example is quantum physics and semiconductors, and, by extension, the Internet itself.
--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 49 mins (2017-10-16 13:10:13 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------
I understand the text to mean that we can't know where a discovery will take us until people start actually doing things with that knowledge. A classic example is quantum physics and semiconductors, and, by extension, the Internet itself.
+1
5 hrs
the way its role is implemented
For the sentence, I think something like: "Or, in other words, everything will tend to evolve in accordance with the way its role is implemented." And I agree with the previous answer, that "its" refers to the Internet.
For me, the difficult word in this sentence is "adherido," typically meaning "acceded" or "adhered," neither of which is very helpful here. A WordReference dictionary lists a meaning of "agree with" for "adherirse" (see below).
For me, the difficult word in this sentence is "adherido," typically meaning "acceded" or "adhered," neither of which is very helpful here. A WordReference dictionary lists a meaning of "agree with" for "adherirse" (see below).
Peer comment(s):
agree |
Alex Ossa
: I find this to be the most accurate way to describe the original intent
20 hrs
|
Thanks, Alex ;-)
|
Something went wrong...